Violence in Close Relationships
Many people view nurturing children as the central aspect of a parent’s job. Just as surely, adults supporting the other adults in a family is also a prescriptive norm – a shared standard for how people ought to behave. However, not all families share such ideals, and even those that do can not only fall short of those ideals, but commit something antithetical to the goals of nurturance, partnership, and support, namely violence.
Violence is a method of dominance, extortion, and conquest. People in higher-power positions seem better situated to use violence for such purposes. For example, a large study of a school in Columbia showed that wealthier children were most likely to be bullies and poorer children most likely to be the bullies’ victims (Chaux & Castellanos, 2011). Similarly, a study of several U.S. primary school children showed that the children they told researchers were the most popular were the children who were rated by the researchers as the most dominant in how they interacted with peers (Lease, Kennedy, & Axelrod, 2002).
However, when an individual commits violence against another individual, his or her motivations may not be any of those things so much as it is to “correct” what they see as their subordination. Bugental and Happaney (2000) show that this is why many parents physically harm their children (read their article to see how they conducted their research without allowing children to be injured). An extensive interview study conducted by Denzin (1984) also finds that men who hit their wives often did so because they felt disempowered. Domestic violence service organizations find that women are more likely to be attacked while they are pregnant — perhaps a sign that their male attackers are jealous. It is, of course, not illogical to understand interpersonal violence as both exercising over others and as an attempt, however, ineffective, of regaining something one has lost, including stature (Anderson, 1997) and even intimacy (Denzin, 1984).
References
Anderson, K. (1997). Gender, Status, and Domestic Violence: An Integration of Feminist and Family Violence Approaches. Journal of Marriage and the Family 59, 655-669 .
Bugental, D. B., Happaney, K. (2000). Parent-child interaction as a power context. Journal of Applied Child Development, 21, 267-282.
Chaux, E. & Castellanos, M. (2014). Money and Power in Schools: Bullying and Power Imbalances. Aggressive Behavior, 41, 280-293. DOI: 10.1002/ab.21558
Lease, A.M., Kennedy, C. A., & Axelrod, J. L. (2007). Children’s Social Constructions of Popularity. Social Development, 11, 87-109.
Additional Resources:
TED Talk: Why domestic violence victims don’t leave
The Atlantic article: How Family Violence Changes the Way Children’s Brains Function
https://www.southbendtribune.com/news/publicsafety/domestic-violence-rises-after-coronavirus-restrictions-south-bend-advocates-say/article_154f9190-96d8-11ea-b9fd-c384514d7212.html